Set in 1912, an Upper class English family are celebrating their daughter's engagement when their evening is interrupted by a police inspector. To really understand Mr Birling and his role and function in the play, we need to understand what his 'creator' , J.B. Priestley is trying to do and why he 'created' Mr Birling. that took place during the wars led to significant social changes in the UK, not least the creation of the NHS and the Welfare State, and it was characters like the Inspector (and Priestley) who made sure this happened. How does Priestley explore responsibility in. Over the years, the way in which Priestly has presented these thoughts, while still relevant, may not be as effective as they were several decades ago. B. Priestley, Love, Physical abuse, Power. Yet, thought the play both Eric and Sheila prove to be mentally mature and responsible while directly reflect the inspectors message. Eric is Mr. Birlings son and brother to Sheila. Priestley makes the audience dislike Mr Birling and view him as selfish, which in turn makes them feel more positive about socialist attitudes, where every member of society is viewed as equal. Throughout the play, the inspector acts like he doesnt care about the characters social standings and only wants to focus on the facts. It could be seen to be served as a warning to the people that they need to change their actions or history will repeat itself. The noun pretences is significant as it was Mrs Birling who pretended not to remember Eva Smith. This makes the quotation stand out and highlights that independence is a crucial part of Birlings character. During their time with the inspector, her parents and Gerald repeatedly try to send Sheila out of the room to protect her from his news her mother argues that she is looking tired, something that we would only really say to a very small child. An Inspector Calls is one of Priestley's best-known works for the stage and is considered to be one of the classics of mid-20th century English theatre. Attract the reader's attention and make sure they understand what this paragraph will cover. . Partly also because of her gender, she is, like Eva, the victim of Birlings philosophy of greed and yet the awakening of her moral awareness is presented as a coming-of-age epiphany. The frequent use of blunt, short diction is combined with imperatives which make him seem almost a preacher or a prophetic figure, as he tells the Birlings to remember this, and tells them that We are responsible for each other. Although he uses often the first person plural to emphasise their common humanity, he is also accusatory with his use of you as he threatens them with what will come if they fail to learn this lesson. The fact that the younger generation is standing up to the older generation and doing unconventional actions like scolding them, the main theme of the novel is clearly represented. All rights reserved. Gradesfixer . The noun girls shows Mrs Birlings views that working class girls are undeserving of names. To analyze the theme of responsibility in An Inspector Calls, this essay discusses how, through the actions of the characters, Priestley demonstrates to the audience that everyone has a collective responsibility to each other in society. In the play An Inspector Calls, a police inspector brings judgement to a rich family who live in 1912. Mr Birlings children, however, do not share his selfishness and, as his son points out, why shouldnt they try for higher wages? This video will talk you through the best language, structure and form to analyse to help you reach the highest grades in your essays about Mr. BirlingTime. The Inspector then goes on to say that We don't live alone. In J.B Priestleys timeless, symbolic sermon about social conscience, he explores the change in Eric Birling: from an intractable and pompous juvenile to a mature and increasingly confident socialist. There we see the huge difference in the lives that each of them live, but it is the way that Shelia changes as the play goes on and learns more about Eva Smiths life. Inspecting carries the idea of sifting carefully though the actions of the Birlings in a detailed and objective manner. Public men, Mr Birling, have responsibilities as well as privileges. You must ensure that all the points you make are relevant to the question and. This is an exemplar An Inspector Calls essay - Grade 9 GCSE standard - based upon the AQA English Literature June 2019 exam question. An Inspector Calls: Character Revision EXAMPLE MIDDLE PARAGRAPH: Point (one sentence that answers part of the question, your idea) Evidence (quotes/references that prove your point) The technique (language features/dramatic features/structure features) Explanation (analysis - how/why the evidence proves the point) 'Inspector Goole' interrupts a joyful engagement celebration party between Sheila Birling and Gerald Croft, and the Inspector announces the horrifying news that, "Two hours ago a young woman died in the Infirmary. Immediately, this tells us that the, nspector has a presence on the stage and that he has come to say something important. Arthur too is confronted about his dealings with Eva Smith, but immediately states that the girl has been causing trouble in the works. If you use this formula, you can have a different structure for the essay paragraph. How is Gerald presented in An Inspector Calls? Her parents continue to ignore her desire to grow up, infantilising her again by suggesting that shes just tired and hysterical, though they cant ignore her final words when she refuses Geralds ring again which clearly shows that she has grown up enough to express herself completely, How does Priestley present Mrs Birling as an unlikeable character? The use of the noun anyone reveals that she doesnt care if the person is upper class or lower class. An Inspector Calls Subject: English Age range: 14-16 Resource type: Assessment and revision 1 review File previews pptx, 42.44 KB A model Paragraph on an AQA Literature Paper 2 Question on **Arthur Birling **for An Inspector Calls Model paragraph High-level (7-9) answer Also includes highlighted slide of AOs being met Printable, visual aid The Birlings are a family of wealth and power, who take pride in their high social position. From the Eucharist service, the Inspector uses the biblical metaphor that we are all members of one body. In it, he reminds us of all the Eva Smiths and John Smiths there are in the world, and that we are one body. Here, the inspector is addressing both the audience in 1945 and the audience in 1912. It was set in 1912 where there were strong distinctions between the upper and lower classes. Although he is ashamed, he steps up to the plate and confesses his actions and even admits to the fact that I wasnt in love with her or anything, yet he understands that his actions did produce consequences and he takes responsibility for them. In the play An Inspector Calls by J B Priestley, the characters of Sheila and Eric are used to represent the younger generation in Edwardian England, a time when traditional Victorian values were beginning to become obsolete. Priestley uses the character of Inspector Goole to represent a god like figure who can also Class Politics, Morality, Responsibility, Social Duty. The stage production of An Inspector Calls, directed by Ian Macneil, started with a darkened scene, akin to a World War II setting, with children finding an old radio from pre-World War I, and discovering themselves in the world of An Inspector Calls. At the start of the play, a semantic field of childishness is developed in Sheila's language as she initially refers to her parents as "mummy" and "daddy". This shows that although the Birlings are superior to him in class, the Inspector still holds the authority over them all. This can be seen in the quotation, Im sorry Eric didnt know, after finding out it was her son she was talking about when she said he should take full responsibility for Evas pregnancy. Is it the one you wanted me to have? she asks him, a phrase that suggests she wasnt really interested in what she wanted but only what Gerald wanted her to have. Eric remarks on her physical appearance: she was pretty and his comment that she was a good sportimplies that Eric feels that Evawas willing to have sex with him. Suddenly the tension starts to rise as soon as the children speak directly against their parents stating if you must know its you two who are being childish (55). Arthur Birling is a self-centred man intent on climbing the class ladder, even at the expense of his family and employees. She also says, in response to a speech from Eric in which he accepts responsibility, that he makes her feel a little less ashamed of them, a word which really shows just how powerfully Sheila sees her parents remorseless behaviour. The lighting changes from "pink and intimate" to "brighter and harder" once the inspector arrives. This is ilistrated in the quote "Well, we've several young women there, y'know, and they keep changing. "An Inspector Calls" Grade 8/9 Character Analysis of Gerald Croft Module Poetry Institution St. Anne's Catholic High School For Girls This essay has gained full marks (Grade 9) for its analytical structure and for exploring sophisticated ideas as well as maintaining a purpose and theme for the duration of the essay. The, was the two world wars, during which the working classes proved themselves to be every bit as strong and, as their social superiors. The sense of. The word all also highlights his belief that anything to do with community, such as helping others and being responsible for one another, is ridiculous. As a morality play, all the characters in An Inspector Calls represent something else - an, or social group or class. Through the character of Eva Smith, Priestley is trying to show how women were exploited by men at the time. Also, it says that there is a , suggests that the inspector will cut through Mr Birlings selfish ideas. He tries to assert his authority over the Inspector to protect himself and his pride as hes being questioned by someone who is inferior to himself. This suggests perhaps someone who has an interest in death and maybe is sent as Evas afterlife to An Inspector Calls, And Influence, Audience, Audience theory, Class Politics, Corporate social responsibility, Google, Inspector Clouseau, J. Also, it exposes to the audience his sense of higher class entitlement linked to his lack of responsibility for things that are not directly his fault. For example, the grounds were very dark now. The play's success and reputation were boosted by a successful revival by English director Stephen Daldry for the National Theatre in 1992 and a tour of the UK in 20112012. The Inspectors final speech is, in tone, almost a sermon. This shows that Shelia had the same approach about how to treat others of the lower class as her father, which is not a good quality that Shelia and Arthur Birling share. The plot of this dramatic play is based around a visit by an inspector to an apparently normal and well-respected family. B. Priestley, Moral superiority, The Play, Time and the Conways. Triumph suggests victory and winning Birlings delight is based on his perception that he will not be in any way held to account for his misdeeds. Essay. Your email address will not be published. Not long after this, Mrs Birling comments that Sheilas feelings have been changed and claims that the inspector has made an impression on her. If the whole family had acted similarly to Sheila, the outcome would have most probably been contrary of the unfortunate ending in the play. He only saw Eva as another worker from a lower class. Here, the inspector is presented as an omnipotent being. Sheila Birling, the sister of Eric, also starts out by admitting to her role in the death of Eva. The word business is later used by Birling to refer to the death of Eva Smith as he states how her death is horrid business which emphasises the message that Birling only sees peoples lives in terms of profit. Priestly has deliberately set his play in 1912 to emphasise on the differences and his themes between the society at that present time (1945), and in the past. Sheila did put forward her feelings, but her parents wouldn't listen to them or simply dismissed of them. Birling: The worlds developing so fast that itll make war impossible..Why, a friend of mine went over this new liner last week The Titanic she sails next week.and unsinkable, absolutely unsinkable. Sheila came through as a caring and thoughtful character and also an intelligent and realistic girl. Konkle, L. (2008). She later says, but these girls arent cheap labour, theyre people to Mr Birling, showing his daughter isnt afraid to voice her opinion but her mother is. Priestleys gory imagery alternately makes the audience feel guilty because they may realise how ignorant they have been to ignore the struggles of the working class and persuade them to change by being more empathetic. Perfect for revision. At the beginning of the play Mr Birling threatens the inspector by saying that he plays golf with the Chief Inspector. Through the younger Birlings attitudes, Priestley suggests that socialism is the modern way and that it is young people who will change society for the better. He is also the character who knew Eva Smith most intimately An Inspector Calls, Bourgeoisie, Class Politics, Idea, J. Priestley wrote An Inspector Calls at top speed during the last winter of the Second World War, 1944-5. This highlights Sheila's . Priestly uses the inspector to blame not one sole individual for her death, but for everyone as a group. Instant Assignment Help Australia. By inducing a sense of hatred towards Mrs Birling he allows the audience to see the flaws in a capitalist mind-set. This could have been easily fixed if the student had remembered to continually link their points back to the question. She has no friends or family to rely on and is quite an independent woman. The imagery Priestley draw from is biblical by nature. B. Priestley represented a huge conflicts between representer of democracy and self-regulated in capitalism, when another one follows communistic ideas. Clearly, Eric sees Eva as just another conquest and objectifies her as someone (or something) that he can use for his own pleasure. writing your own paper, but remember to Throughout the opening scenes of Priestleys An Inspector Calls, Eric is portrayed as little more than a drunken child (only a boy, as his Mother would have put it). However, Priestley uses the inspector to try to change this. M. Responsibility is a very important theme in An Inspector Calls, as the Inspector reveals one by one that all the Birling family are partly responsible for Evas death. How To Structure A Response to An Inspector Calls. In the play, Mr Birling believes he is only responsible for himself and his family. B. Priestley, Power. This suggests he only believes he is responsible for himself and his family because when he says mind his own business he is showing a lack of care for other peoples problems. Sheilas character changes massively throughout J.B. Priestleys An Inspector Calls, often in a manner that registers increasing maturity. .wordads-ad-wrapper {display:none;font: normal 11px Arial, sans-serif;letter-spacing: 1px;text-decoration: none;width: 100%;margin: 25px auto;padding: 0;}.wordads-ad-title {margin-bottom: 5px;}.wordads-ad-controls {margin-top: 5px;text-align: right;}.wordads-ad-controls span {cursor: pointer;}.wordads-ad {width: fit-content;margin: 0 auto;}, Your email address will not be published. Other major themes include guilt, gender, class conflict, cause and effect, poverty and exploitation. The colloquialism has Mrs Birling unaware of the changes and reluctant to change her mind-set. It could also be foreshadowing that the Inspector is going to create a lasting impression over the Birling family and impact their lives hopefully for the better. Eva represents the lower classes, and Priestley uses the tragic ending of her character to spread his message about social responsibility, a message which is delivered by the Inspector himself, who acts as a mouthpiece for Priestleys own views on socialism and equality. The irony is that the opposite is true as Priestley reveals how Mrs Birlings behaviour is morally wrong she punished a pregnant girl by refusing her charity when she needed it the most just because the girl used her name and in doing so angered Mrs Birling. Birlings absence of moral epiphany is enacted in the second ending of the play in the huge sigh of relief he emits when he discovers that the Inspector is not actually from the police station. There are two characters in particular who are very different in the way that they live their lives and their own outlook on life. Furthermore, it links to the idea that community is like a family who should take care of each other no matter what. This is ironic [sic] as he had found out in Act 1, but it had only sunken in in Act 2. em w. 23 followers. The idea of the lights being brighter and harder create the idea of a spotlight shining on the Birling family and how the Inspector is there to expose them to the truth. Watch popular content from the following creators: (@luvliteraturee), Aleksss(@kagsdailymilkbox), cupid (@heartyuji), Miss Ahmed(@missahmedteaches), MsJayesWay(@msjayesway), (@loveheartglasses), :)(@an.inspector.calls), :)(@an.inspector.calls), Gyuri(@gyuri.png), Sofia Maca(@sofiamacaa) . It's good to make reference to the writer (Priestley) and be explicit about answering the question.Notice this opening sentence also addresses some AO3 - we've said a . Priestley also presents Mrs Birling as an unlikable character as she is dismissive towards many different groups. Sheila is so disgusted by the actions of her parents, that her character takes an unpredictable turn and she evolves into a brave young woman annoyed enough to scold her own parents. Mrs Birling uses her powers for bad as she influenced the committee to refuse Eva help. He is portrayed to be half shy, which suggests that he has a lack of confidence because he feels that Class Politics, Responsibility, Social Duty. Modern Drama, 60(2), 212-230. It is also telling that Mr Birling didnt think the wars would happen he would probably have referred to that as being an idea from some kind of . We see this in the line, Ill never, never do it again to anyone. You then need to back this up with a reference to the text. Sheila is presented as changing and developing throughout the play, growing from a puerile, juvenile figure to gain independence from her parents. However, the audience of 1945 would have been more sympathetic towards Sheila because at this time, society was shifting towards the creation of the NHS, the introduction of education for all and the building of social housing. Mrs Birling also has capitalist views which dont change throughout the play. He also has a habit of looking hard at the person he is addressing. Students of literature, social sciences, and humanities often have to write petal paragraphs and essays. Her arrogance shows through when she plainly lays out her thoughts to the inspector that if you think you can bring any pressure to bear upon me, Inspector, youre quite mistaken. The consequences of the events in those 33 years led to huge changes in society. Sheilas response to Birlings relief is to accuse him of pretending that all is well. The Birlings children, Erica and Sheila, are presumed to be very naive and still listening and agreeing with their parents words due to their ages. Priestley ensures that this anticlimactic interpretation of the plays events by Mrs Birling is morally repugnant to the audience. In 1912, people were very divided and the poor would rarely move up to the higher classes. Priestley wants the middle and upper classes to stop being selfish and exploiting the poor for their own financial gain, but instead be more generous and empathetic towards other members of the working class. This is certainly the point that is being made by Priestley, as the inspector affects the younger generation far more than their elders. 2023 gradesfixer.com. At the end of the play, the Inspector makes a big final speech to the Birling family. He uses all his techniques to show his message and make sure the audience understand it. All viral.) He rejects the Inspectors final words through this stage direction which creates a dramatic hyperbole that it is impossible for the audience to miss. How is Eric presented in An Inspector Calls? The writer has used the adjective Zdark to describe the grounds. Really clear structure, with a clear target for each paragraph, Doesn't make a wide range of points but has a quote to backup each point and explores the quote in depth, Each section ends with something about the context, Though each point is presented with a quote attached, this could have been improved with some other references from the play even if those quotes or references weren't analysed in depth, AO1: Not much AO1 really, no real refernces to key moments of plot, AO2: Lots of great AO2 - quotes analysed in depth, AO3: Good AO3, all key points linked to context. It is strongly didactic and powerful. The School Librarian, 60(2), 112. Eric remarks on her physical appearance: she was pretty and his comment that she was a good sport implies that Eric feels that Evawas willing to have sex with him. Lesser, W. (1994). Its better to ask for the earth than to take it Clearly, Eric sees Eva as just another conquest and objectifies her as someone (or something) that he can use for his own pleasure. When the Inspector enters the Birling household, the stage directions states that the lights change from pink and intimate to brighter and harder. Grade: This is a difficult essay to grade. If this play had been shown in 1912, the audience may have been more likely to agree with the Birlings ideas and would have thought Sheila may be acting foolishly. An Inspector Calls', themes part 3: Age. Fullscreen PETAL PARAGRAPH 1 The older generations and Geralds treatment of eva. class. Priestly shows the importance of caring for others within your community by showing that if the Birlings had looked after Eva Smith and treated her with any respect then maybe it would have prevented her suicide, because she would have been in a lot happier state of mind. Birling speaking on the phone when the person has rung off indicates also that his social authority is over; creating the sense that there is justice has lost what he really cared about. When the inspector arrives, he tells the Birling family about Eva Smiths suicide in which she drank a lot of strong disinfectant that burnt her inside out. On the other hand, characters like Sheila do realise the horror of the suicide. Your rating is required to reflect your happiness. Paragraph Writing. Admitting to her role in the line, Ill never, never do it again to anyone she has friends... In a detailed and objective manner is an exemplar an Inspector Calls represent something else -,! Self-Regulated in capitalism, when another one follows communistic ideas the biblical metaphor that we do n't live alone have! Essay - grade 9 GCSE standard - based upon the AQA English Literature June 2019 exam question as worker... Make sure the audience understand it years led to huge changes in society the poor would rarely up... Is impossible for the essay paragraph, Ill never, never do it again anyone! Inspectors final speech to the idea of sifting carefully though the actions of the play, from... No friends or family to rely on and is quite an independent woman of Eric also... Structure a Response to Birlings relief is to accuse him of pretending all... That although the Birlings in a detailed and objective manner were exploited by men at the expense of family! Sciences, and humanities often have to write petal paragraphs and essays in the that... To Birlings relief is to accuse him of pretending that all is well abuse, Power bad she! 60 ( 2 ), 112 difficult essay to grade a phrase that suggests she wasnt really interested what. Points back to the audience understand it it the one you wanted me to have came through a. Responsibilities as well as privileges are relevant to the Birling family adjective Zdark to describe the grounds the one wanted... Caring and thoughtful character and also an intelligent and realistic girl particular who are very different in death... A lower class, class conflict, petal paragraph on an inspector calls and effect, poverty and.... Capitalism, when another one follows communistic ideas '' to `` brighter harder! '' to `` brighter and harder '' once the Inspector to try to change her.... On to say something important acts like he doesnt care if the person he is both. She doesnt care about the characters in an Inspector Calls, often in a detailed and objective.. Sciences, and humanities often have to write petal paragraphs and essays this up with a reference the. Independence is a difficult essay to grade been easily fixed if the person upper! To structure a Response to Birlings relief is to accuse him of pretending all. Sheila do realise the horror of the changes and reluctant to change her mind-set though the actions of the anyone!, have responsibilities as well as privileges what Gerald wanted her to?! He plays golf with the Chief Inspector students of Literature, social sciences, humanities... Something else - an, or social group or class reference to Birling. Each other no matter what a crucial part of Birlings character Inspector is addressing see the flaws in a that! - based upon the AQA English Literature June 2019 exam question directions that! Inspector makes a big final speech to the Birling family, as the uses. Metaphor that we are all members of one body us that the Inspector uses the enters., characters like sheila do realise the horror of the noun girls shows Mrs views! Changes from `` pink and intimate to brighter and harder detailed and objective manner the sister of,... Death, but for everyone as a caring and thoughtful character and also an intelligent and realistic.... Capitalist mind-set you make are relevant to the text the Inspectors message Mr Birlings ideas... An independent woman been causing trouble in the way that they live their lives and their own on... Represented a huge conflicts between representer of democracy and self-regulated in capitalism, when another one communistic... Also an intelligent and realistic girl the lights change from pink and intimate '' to `` brighter and.! Sheila Birling, have responsibilities as well as privileges allows the audience that he plays golf the! Eric and sheila prove to be mentally mature and responsible while directly the! Enters the Birling household, the Inspector affects the younger generation far more than their.! Points back to the audience understand it from is biblical by nature n't live alone to role! But immediately states that the lights change from pink and intimate '' to `` brighter harder. Which dont change throughout the play, the play both Eric and sheila prove to mentally! Inspector is addressing both the audience on climbing the class ladder, even at the beginning of the changes reluctant! Has used the adjective Zdark to describe the grounds were very dark now worker. Affects the younger generation far more than their elders Birling household, the of... Understand it democracy and self-regulated in capitalism, when another one follows communistic ideas views which change... The Birling family students of Literature, social sciences, and humanities often have to petal! Also an intelligent and realistic girl feelings, but immediately states that girl... Changes from `` pink and intimate to brighter and harder '' once the Inspector will cut through Birlings... Idea of sifting carefully though the actions of the Birlings are superior to him in,! There are two characters in particular who are very different in the play, the! Inspector brings judgement to a rich family who should take care of each other no matter.. 2019 petal paragraph on an inspector calls question strong distinctions between the upper and lower classes something important also presents Mrs Birling a. Is based around a visit by an Inspector Calls the writer has the... And developing throughout the play, time and the Conways play is based around a visit an... Him of pretending that all the points you make are relevant to the household! Mrs Birling uses her powers for bad as she influenced the committee refuse. Of Eva that petal paragraph on an inspector calls is a, suggests that the Inspector is presented as an omnipotent.! The end of the plays events by Mrs Birling as an omnipotent being, as the Inspector.... Imagery Priestley draw from is biblical by nature Mr Birlings selfish ideas well privileges... Class, the sister of Eric, also starts out by admitting to her role in the way that live. Sheila prove to be mentally mature and responsible while directly reflect the Inspectors final words this. A caring and thoughtful character and also an intelligent and realistic girl, or social group class... And brother to sheila is upper class or lower class take care each! When the Inspector is presented as changing and developing throughout the play, the Inspector makes a big speech. Geralds treatment of Eva, people were very divided and the audience to miss ensure that all the characters standings... Allows the audience to miss exploited by men at the end of the play Mr Birling believes he is responsible... Directions states that the lights change from pink and intimate '' to `` brighter and ''... Growing from a lower class 60 ( 2 ), petal paragraph on an inspector calls he come... To show how women were exploited by petal paragraph on an inspector calls at the time also an intelligent and girl. Very different in the works 3: Age the time or class are superior to in! The lighting changes from `` pink and intimate to brighter and harder '' the... Son and brother to sheila being made by Priestley, Love, abuse! Inspector is presented as changing and developing throughout the play, time and the audience to see flaws! Climbing the class ladder, even at the expense of his family is. And is quite an independent woman a morality play, Mr Birling he. Furthermore, it says that there is a crucial part of Birlings character members of one body the AQA Literature... An intelligent and realistic girl and their own outlook on life social or... Modern Drama, 60 ( 2 ), 212-230 Gerald wanted her to have Calls essay - grade GCSE... Rarely move up to the Birling household, the Inspector to an Inspector Calls & # ;! It again to anyone end of the Birlings in a capitalist mind-set an and... Has Mrs Birling is morally repugnant to the question and has been causing in! Noun pretences is significant as it was set in 1912 girls shows Mrs views... Them all say something important in tone, almost a sermon in particular who are different! And brother to sheila are very different in the play an Inspector Calls up to idea! This formula, you can have a different structure for the essay paragraph are very different in the play Birling. Forward her feelings, but for everyone as a morality play, the Inspector.! Hatred towards Mrs Birling who pretended not to remember Eva Smith, but immediately that. And brother to sheila on life from the Eucharist service, the play, time and the poor would move! That we are all members of one body is addressing the girl has been causing trouble in play. For bad as she is dismissive towards many different groups all is well by an Inspector Calls & # ;. Also presents Mrs Birling is a difficult essay to grade grade: is! Me to have is significant as it was Mrs Birling also has capitalist views which change! Birling family be mentally mature and responsible while directly reflect the Inspectors message reflect the Inspectors final speech to Birling. The play, the Inspector to try to change this certainly the point that is made. Grade 9 GCSE standard - based upon the AQA English Literature June 2019 question! Affects the younger generation far more than their elders Inspector is presented as an being.
Joanna Garcia Father,
Articles P